Disk Quality Scan Thread

[soup]

I am going to post the Samsung scan but I scanned it with the Samsung. I am starting to distrust the LiteON when it comes to scanning because I looked at a couple of old scans from April with TYG03s, (not from the same spindle) & they looked great. I have a couple of more tests to run & try to verify.



One from April but scanned with the Samsung.

[NightTran]

why dont you scan the same disc with both liteon and samsung? ( leave time in between for the disc to cool off?

[Dan]

Definitely some strange things going on there.

Just curious, are all of these scans with the newest cd speed 4.7.5.0?

I have never liked the new version, found it too buggy with my Samsung.
I wondering what effect it might have on the Lite-On even though it seems suited for that type of burner??

[soup]

@ NightTran, that's the couple of tests I have to do.

@ Dan, yes.

[soup]

First scan with the Samsung, second pic was the second attempt at a scan with the LiteOn. CdDvd speed quit 3/4 of the way through the first one, QS was @77. I might post the cool down scans tomorrow, kind of getting my fill of scanning, if you know what I mean.

[locoeng]

Has anyone played with the burn feature of CD/DVD Speed? Out of curiosity I used it to burn a disc the other day and don't really know how to interpret the results....although if you ask me, looking at all those squiggly lines I woudln't think it is great.



...and here is a disc burned with DVD2One's burn engine.

[soup]

First burn with LH20A1S (9L07 FB). Sony Dvd-R 16X, 50 pack spindle, TYG03 Made in Japan. First scan with LH20A1S (9L07 FB), second scan with SH-162L (TS08) directly after.

[Chewy]

that's a puzzler, wonder if the sata connection or firmware is messing up the scanning

I would trust the samsung on this more, wish you had a benq or a pata liteon to confirm tho

[NightTran]

I would take the old plextor out and check which one is reliable

[soup]

More.

Same media but burned @12X. This time the first one is the Samsung. @ NightTran, the Plextor is still connected & still gets used a lot. Did you mean do a burn with the plextor with this media & scan with both?





This is not a comparison Chewy but just in case somebody thought the LiteON was to new for that version of CDDVD Speed.



PlexTools TA Test.

8X:

12X:

[NightTran]

no I mean use the plextor scan from the disc you scan with both above then see where it close to

[soup]

Verbatim Dvd+R 16X, 100 pack spindle, Made in Taiwan, MID MCC004. Burned @8X with ImgBurn & LH-20A1S 9L07 FB. First scan Samsung, second scan LiteON.

[NightTran]

I dont know if I remember it right but my last lighton I had to scan at 4x

Just making you work more Soup

[soup]

Well when these are approved you will see that they are comparable, so I think it is down to LiteON & Dvd-R media. Not that I am scared of more work.

[soup]

Sony Dvd+R 8X 50 Pack Spindle MIJ YUDENT02.

Burned with ImgBurn & TSST SH-S182D SB06, scanned with TSST SH-162L TS08 @8X.

4X:

6X:

8X: