Why o why

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Dynamic One
    Junior Member
    Junior Member
    • Feb 2002
    • 7

    Why o why

    Still don't get it

    Have converted a movie from avi 2 mpg. The size of the movie is :300 MB, But when I want 2 make it VCD the file becomes 803 MB or larger. What Am I doing wrong ???
  • Enchanter
    Old member
    • Feb 2002
    • 5417

    #2
    Is 300MB the size of the mpg or avi file?

    Comment

    • Dynamic One
      Junior Member
      Junior Member
      • Feb 2002
      • 7

      #3
      The avi file 300 MB

      Comment

      • benderman
        Digital Video Specialist
        Digital Video Specialist
        • Nov 2001
        • 770

        #4
        MPEG1 dosen't compress as good as divx-avi. So normal VCD needs about 600MB per hour. If you choose a lower bitrate you might be able to produce a smaller file, but you will also loose some quality.
        don't trust in guides

        Comment

        • Enchanter
          Old member
          • Feb 2002
          • 5417

          #5
          As stated above, when you convert the avi to mpg, the resulting file will be bigger. Depending on the type of VCD (Normal or SVCD) you're planning to make, what you should be more worried about is the total length of the movie and hence how many CDs will be required. After you've got the CDs done, you can always delete the gargantuan mpg file (if i may call it so).

          Comment

          • Dynamic One
            Junior Member
            Junior Member
            • Feb 2002
            • 7

            #6
            Here are the spec:

            Chicken run.avi
            Width: 640 Pixels
            Heigth: 352 Pixels
            Length: 1:20:56
            Bitspeed: 64 Kbps ??
            Sound: 16 Bits
            Sound: Divx Audio
            Framespeed: 25 Frames/sec
            Propertyspeed: 74Kbps
            Heigth Frame: 24 Bits
            Compression: DivxMpg4 V3

            ------------------------------------------------
            Chicken run.Mpg
            Width: 640 Pixels
            Heigth: 352 Pixels
            Length: 1:20:56
            Bitspeed: 64 Kbps ??
            Sound: 16 Bits
            Sound: Divx Audio
            Framespeed: 25 Frames/sec
            Propertyspeed: 74Kbps
            Heigth Frame: 24 Bits
            Compression: DivxMpg4 V3


            The Chiken run.mpg file is: 807.137 kb
            No information about this file

            Comment

            • setarip
              Retired
              • Dec 2001
              • 24955

              #7
              "Chicken run.Mpg
              Width: 640 Pixels
              Heigth: 352 Pixels
              Length: 1:20:56
              Bitspeed: 64 Kbps ??
              Sound: 16 Bits
              Sound: Divx Audio
              Framespeed: 25 Frames/sec
              Propertyspeed: 74Kbps
              Heigth Frame: 24 Bits
              Compression: DivxMpg4 V3"

              What software are you using to create the MPEG1 file? Where did you find this information that I've quoted?
              I ask because if, in fact you've made a proper MPEG1 file, some of the above is fallacious - The compression (video) would no longer be DivxMpg4V3, rather it would be MPEG1. The audio (typically) would be MPEG1-Layer II.

              Also, if you want to create a conforming PAL VCD (which is a modified MPEG1 format) you should convert the file to 352x288 - which will also reduce the filesize.

              Comment

              • Dynamic One
                Junior Member
                Junior Member
                • Feb 2002
                • 7

                #8
                I used Virtualdub.

                Comment

                • Enchanter
                  Old member
                  • Feb 2002
                  • 5417

                  #9
                  TMPGEnc would be the more proper software to use for creating VCD-compliant mpg files.

                  Comment

                  • setarip
                    Retired
                    • Dec 2001
                    • 24955

                    #10
                    "I used Virtualdub."

                    I'm afraid not - VirtualDub is only capable of output in .AVI format. Therefore, there is no way you can have created an MPEG1 file usnig only VirtualDub.

                    I hope you're not just "trying to have a little fun" here...

                    Comment

                    Working...