having troubles with TMPGEnc

**setarip** · 1 Feb 2003, 06:29 AM

A few suggestions, if I may, which you certainly can feel free to disregard:

1) Split your 3 Gig .AVI into two .AVIs
2) Upmixing the audio from a frequency of 44,100Hz to 48,000Hz is not a good idea and, perhaps more importantly, will not in any way improve it
3) There is nothing to be gained by changing the framerate from 23.976Fps to 29.976Fps
4) Increasing the resolution from 640x272 to 720x480 (or 720x306) will result in a poorer quality image (The ONLY reason for increasing to this resolution would be if you were creating a DVD)

**Slain** · 1 Feb 2003, 03:19 PM

cool

actually im trying to make a dvd... i will try your other suggestions though. thanks a bunch! if they dont work.. ill probably reply to this message sometime tomorrow.
Slain

**setarip** · 1 Feb 2003, 04:17 PM

"thanks a bunch!"

My pleasure ;>}

**Ndb** · 2 Feb 2003, 01:19 PM

Slain

What you have is a bad frame in the source avi mate.

You see TMPGenc is a lot less tolerent to bad frames than Mediaplayer etc. Run the file through VirtualDub and get it to check for bad frames. Some times just running it through V-Dub with "direct stream copy" can clean out junk.

If your wave is seperate then you must mux it in V-Dub before you chop any bad frames or your audio will be longer than your video and get sync probs.

Also get hold of GoldWave and run your wave file through it to resample to 48khz, as TMPGenc is not that good at upsampling from 44-48, it can introduce noise.

Setarip

points 2) 3) & 4) are incorrect for MPEG2 creation, as you only really convert to MPEG2 for SVCD or DVD (IMHO) and 48khz audio, 23-29 (with 3:2 pd) & a compatible AR (720x480/576 for DVD) are all needed for this. The 720x306 is for 4:3 Letter Boxed 2.35:1 movie.

Everything is always IMHO Ndb

)

**setarip** · 3 Feb 2003, 03:46 AM

To Ndb

1) 48,000Hz is not REQUIRED for SVCD - 44,100Hz does just fine

2) 23.976Fps (NTSC Film), likewise does just fine for SVCD

3) Lastly, my original statement "4) Increasing the resolution from 640x272 to 720x480 (or 720x306) will result in a poorer quality image (The ONLY reason for increasing to this resolution would be if you were creating a DVD)" - is in no way, that I see, contradicted by what you've said

And by all means, do keep in mind that my first response (the one you've addressed) was based on Slain's initial post, to wit:

"I have an xvid file that i want to transcode into an mpeg 2."

P.S. Re: your comment, "as you only really convert to MPEG2 for SVCD or DVD (IMHO)" - Actually, there's a "world" of MPEG-2s floating around the 'Net...

**Slain** · 3 Feb 2003, 08:42 AM

thanks....

Well i figured out that i did have a bad frame in the video... its hardly noticeable, but its there. So i deleted it and it works fine now. Thanks to both of you, and no need to get at each others throats

Slain

**setarip** · 3 Feb 2003, 08:53 AM

Congratulations on resolving your dilemma - despite us ;>}

(Don't misinterpret friendly differences of opinion as "being at each others throats - it's just a normal part of constantly growing and learning...)

having troubles with TMPGEnc

having troubles with TMPGEnc

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment